Home > Policy > Standardized Testing

Standardized Testing in SD and its Impact

By South Dakota Education Monitor Editorial Team | Sourced from SD DOE

This article outlines South Dakota's standardized testing requirements, explaining the Smarter Balanced assessments and how scores impact school accountability report cards.

Testing Requirements in SD
The Smarter Balanced Assessment
School Accountability and Report Cards
The Testing Debate and Local Control
Accommodations and Alternative Testing

Testing Requirements in SD

South Dakota requires all public school students in grades 3 through 8 and grade 11 to participate in annual standardized testing. These assessments are designed to measure student proficiency in core academic standards, track annual progress, and ensure school accountability under state and federal education laws.

The Smarter Balanced Assessment

The primary testing instrument used in South Dakota is the Smarter Balanced assessment, which evaluates student skills in English Language Arts (ELA) and Mathematics. These computer-adaptive tests adjust question difficulty based on student responses, providing a precise measure of academic ability. The state also administers the South Dakota Science Assessment to students in grades 5, 8, and 11.

School Accountability and Report Cards

Standardized test scores are a major component of the South Dakota School Accountability System. The state issues annual Report Cards for each public school, evaluating metrics such as academic achievement, student growth, English learner progress, and graduation rates. Schools with persistently low scores may receive targeted state intervention and support to improve instruction.

The Testing Debate and Local Control

While state officials emphasize the value of standardized testing for tracking academic performance, the practice faces criticism from some educators and parents. Critics argue that high-stakes testing can lead to "teaching to the test," narrows the curriculum, and causes unnecessary anxiety for students. This has led to debates over local control and the potential use of alternative assessments.

Accommodations and Alternative Testing

To ensure fairness, South Dakota provides testing accommodations for students with disabilities and English language learners. Accommodations include extended testing time, read-aloud support, or simplified instructions. For students with significant cognitive disabilities, the state administers the MSAA (Multi-State Alternative Assessment), which matches their individualized education program (IEP) goals.

Patricia Halverson, M.Ed. — Senior Education Policy Analyst

Patricia has over 15 years of experience researching public K-12 funding structures, school boards, and legislative updates in South Dakota. She is a former policy consultant to regional school boards and focuses on local education finance and tax levies.